In the Saddle at Saddleback

It was a study in contrasts with Obama and McCain at the Saddleback forum.

Obama came across as thoughtful and as one who seeks common ground. McCain was right at home in a forum that welcomed enthusiastically a right wing perspective. Sensing that, McCain shifted into full wingnut mode to show that he was one of them, leaving no cliche answer unturned.

Who does this help? Not McCain. McCain already had the votes of those who would be impressed with declaring himself an ultra-conservative. And as far as his moldy oldie stories, those can play pretty well across the board, but they're going to resonate best with his base.

Obama had the upper hand ultimately for this reason, because he was able to come across as kind, rational, and thoughtful. He addressed the moderator in a very respectful way, "Pastor Rick." He was searching for actual answers to the questions, not spouting talking points as McCain did.

I would say McCain held his own, but Obama picked up some votes. Net gain, Obama.